We may earn a commission from links on this page.
Just a few months ago, Oura won a lawsuit against rival smart ring makers Ultrahuman and RingConn. Now, they’ve initiated proceedings against four more companies—the makers of the Samsung Galaxy Ring, Reebok Smart Ring, Amazfit Helio Ring, and the Luna Ring.
Oura announced on their website that they have filed an ITC complaint against those four companies. The ITC is the U.S. International Trade Commission, and Oura says its complaint is “for the unlawful importation and sale of products that infringe on several of Oura’s patents.”
Oura’s previous win against Ultrahuman and RingConn resulted in a judgment that those companies had to stop selling and importing their smart rings. RingConn ultimately came to an agreement with Oura to license their patents and continue selling their rings. Circular and Omate have made similar agreements with Oura.
Ultrahuman no longer sells their ring in the U.S., but is working on a new ring design that would sidestep the alleged patent infringement. You can read Ultrahuman’s take on the situation in this blog post, which also includes a promise to continue supporting rings that they have already sold or that people may buy from resellers.
What do you think so far?
The rings in the recent complaint should still be available for a while. Oura says on their blog: “So what’s next? The ITC process will run its course.” There’s no guarantee that Oura will win their case, although the fact they were able to get such a sweeping judgment against other companies suggests that it’s not too much of a long shot.
While Oura’s communications around this issue use phrases like “respect for IP” (that is, intellectual property), as a consumer and a reviewer, I hate to see an exciting tech area get dominated by a single player or, worse, shut down by that player piece by piece. I’m working on a review of the Luna ring, which I’ve previously noted has some serious potential improvements over other rings on the market. Here’s hoping the smart ring category remains a lively one going forward.