Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    The Garmin Cirqa Finally Got a Much-Needed Feature

    October 26, 2026

    25 Simple Hacks That’ll Improve Your Quality Of Life

    October 26, 2026

    She Bootstrapped Her Way to 7 Figures. Here’s How a Big Nordstrom Win Signaled It Was Time to Raise.

    October 26, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • The Garmin Cirqa Finally Got a Much-Needed Feature
    • 25 Simple Hacks That’ll Improve Your Quality Of Life
    • She Bootstrapped Her Way to 7 Figures. Here’s How a Big Nordstrom Win Signaled It Was Time to Raise.
    • Fewer people are flying, but airlines aren’t worried
    • Latvia targets tokenization rules in 2027 with commercial property in focus
    • Mark Zuckerberg Makes Deal To Help Pay Proposed Billionaire Tax
    • Troy Jackson’s Closing Argument: ‘A Vote For Susan Collins Is A Vote For Trump’
    • How to identify content gaps for AI visibility
    Facebook X (Twitter)
    SBM Global News
    Demo
    • Home
    • Top Stories
      • Politics
    • Business
      • Small Business
      • Marketing
    • Finance
      • Investment
    • Technology

      Starlink seems to be working normally again in Ukraine

      October 25, 2026
      Read More

      10 Frequently Asked Questions About Claude

      October 24, 2026
      Read More

      Agent cloud startup Daytona hits $1B valuation backed by FirstMark and a who’s who of angels

      October 24, 2026
      Read More

      Tesla says it will start selling Cybercabs by end of year

      October 22, 2026
      Read More

      Eric Schmidt reportedly owns about half as much of Anthropic as CEO Dario Amodei

      October 21, 2026
      Read More
    • Lifestyle
      • Travel
    • Feel Good
    • Get In Touch
    SBM Global News
    Demo
    Home»Business»He Paid $13 for $13,000 Cartier Earrings, and Then the Jeweler Noticed
    Business

    He Paid $13 for $13,000 Cartier Earrings, and Then the Jeweler Noticed

    By Staff WriterApril 29, 20245 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Reddit Email
    #image_title
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Rogelio Villarreal knew nothing about the French jeweler Cartier, he said, when an ad popped up on his Instagram feed last December. He clicked on it, perusing the pages of bling and other luxury items, including handbags, watches and necklaces, each listed for thousands of dollars.

    Then Mr. Villarreal, who lives in Mexico, noticed a pair of earrings: slender studded 18-carat rose-gold cuffs lined with diamonds, priced at just 237 Mexican pesos, or about $13.

    “I was amazed to see how much the necklaces cost and so on and I said: ‘Someday,’ until I saw the earrings,” Mr. Villarreal, 27, wrote on social media. “I swear I broke out in a cold sweat.”

    He bought two pairs. Later, the price for the earrings was adjusted on the Cartier website to 237,000 pesos — more than $13,000.

    The purchase initiated a monthslong tussle between Mr. Villarreal, a surgery resident from the northern state of Tamaulipas, and Cartier, with hundreds of social media users following along — some cheering, others taunting — and even a Mexican senator weighing in on the dispute. But Mr. Villarreal said on Friday that he had received the earrings for the steeply discounted price and noted that he had a special person in mind to be their recipient.

    “I’m excited,” he said, “especially for my mom. Those earrings are for her.”

    The sweet deal did not come without some resistance.

    Within a week of the purchase, Mr. Villarreal said, Cartier began a series of attempts to cancel the order, initially saying that the earrings were not available.

    When Mr. Villarreal made no move to cancel the order, he started receiving phone calls from company representatives.

    He said they told him that “the earrings that I had ordered were not at the correct price, which is why they wanted to cancel the purchase, and that because of the inconvenience they would give me a gift.”

    As “compensation,” the company then offered “a gesture from the house of Cartier” — a complimentary bottle of Cartier Cuvée champagne and a leather Cartier item, according to an email sent to Mr. Villarreal.

    He decided to reject the gifts and fight back, using a contact form on the company’s website to cite a federal consumer protection law in Mexico that says that a goods supplier can be taken to court “by not respecting the terms and conditions under which” a product or service is purchased.

    Cartier has not responded to several requests for comment.

    Mr. Villarreal found the terms and conditions for sales on Cartier’s website in Mexico, which state that any dispute could be brought to the Office of the Federal Prosecutor for the Consumer for “conciliation.”

    Demo

    So he did just that. He filed a complaint with the Matamoros branch of the federal consumer protection agency.

    The agency, which has a role similar to that of the Federal Trade Commission in the United States, has a history of intervening on behalf of consumers when retailers change list prices after a sale.

    In February, the consumer agency invited consumers to join a class-action lawsuit against Sony, which had canceled orders for a PlayStation 5 console that it had offered on its website in Mexico for a 30 percent discount.

    The consumer protection law is so well known in Mexico that people use social media to draw attention to erroneous prices on Amazon and other retailers’ websites in posts that are widely seen and shared, according to El Economista, a newspaper in Mexico City that covers financial news.

    Mr. Villarreal said that the consumer agency had summoned Cartier for arbitration and that the government had made several attempts to mediate an agreement. Agency officials said they could not share information about an open case with anyone other than the parties involved.

    If the consumer protection agency finds that a company is at fault, it can impose fines or other penalties, but it can’t force a company to abide by a price it listed, said Jorge López Zozaya, a corporate lawyer in Mexico City. If no agreement is reached, either party can ask for a judge to resolve the complaint.

    Mexican law does not extend protections to consumers if a listed price was clearly a mistake, Mr. Zozaya said.

    “If this case had gone to a court of law, it probably would have resolved favorably for Cartier,” Mr. Zozaya said.

    But there appeared to be a truce in the matter. Ahead of a consumer agency mediation hearing next week, Mr. Villarreal said on Monday that he had received notice from Cartier that his order would be fulfilled, and then announced the earrings’ delivery on Friday. The agreement could not be confirmed with Cartier or the agency.

    “War is over,” he wrote in English in a social media post on Monday.

    Mr. Villarreal said on Friday that the earrings arrived, and he shared a photo of two small boxes wrapped in paper with wax seals. “Once upon a December,” he wrote in the social media post.

    Some users applauded his tenaciousness in getting Cartier to comply with the terms of his purchase, while others, including a Mexican senator, had accused him of abusing the consumer protection system for his own gain.

    “It is wrong to take advantage of a mistake to the detriment of another person,” wrote Lilly Téllez, a senator from the state of Sonora, adding, “even if the law supports you.”

    Mr. Villarreal said that he was happy that the ordeal was over and that he would sign an agreement to settle his complaint with the consumer protection agency.

    Elda Cantú contributed reporting from Mexico City.



    View original article here

    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Reddit
    Previous ArticleThe Betrayal 
    Next Article Travelers Share Unforgettable Blunders That Haunt Them

    Related Posts

    Women Sluggers Are No Longer in a League of Their Own

    September 27, 2026
    Read More

    Elizabeth Holmes to Transfer to Halfway House in August 2027

    September 24, 2026
    Read More

    Anthropic Quietly Sets Up Biology Lab As It Ramps AI Drug Program

    September 19, 2026
    Read More
    Add A Comment

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Demo
    Top Posts

    Former FBI, CIA Head Has ‘Serious Concerns’ With Trump Cabinet Picks

    December 28, 2024435

    Emirates to operate next-gen A350 on the third daily service to Cape Town

    January 14, 2026256

    AAVE Price Prediction: Target $215-225 by Mid-January 2025 as Technical Indicators Signal Bullish Momentum

    December 15, 2025240

    Wall Street Slumps As Alphabet, Qualcomm And Other Tech Stocks Fall

    February 7, 2026212
    Don't Miss
    Lifestyle

    The Garmin Cirqa Finally Got a Much-Needed Feature

    By Staff WriterOctober 26, 20263 Mins Read

    We may earn a commission from links on this page. This week Garmin’s screenless Cirqa…

    Read More

    25 Simple Hacks That’ll Improve Your Quality Of Life

    October 26, 2026

    She Bootstrapped Her Way to 7 Figures. Here’s How a Big Nordstrom Win Signaled It Was Time to Raise.

    October 26, 2026

    Fewer people are flying, but airlines aren’t worried

    October 26, 2026
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    Demo
    Find More
    Trending News
    • The Garmin Cirqa Finally Got a Much-Needed Feature
    • 25 Simple Hacks That’ll Improve Your Quality Of Life
    • She Bootstrapped Her Way to 7 Figures. Here’s How a Big Nordstrom Win Signaled It Was Time to Raise.
    • Fewer people are flying, but airlines aren’t worried
    • Latvia targets tokenization rules in 2027 with commercial property in focus
    • Mark Zuckerberg Makes Deal To Help Pay Proposed Billionaire Tax
    • Troy Jackson’s Closing Argument: ‘A Vote For Susan Collins Is A Vote For Trump’
    • How to identify content gaps for AI visibility
    • Starlink seems to be working normally again in Ukraine
    • Financial Planners Share 5 Tips To Get The Most Out Of Your 401(k)
    Other News
    • Business
    • Feel Good
    • Finance
    • Fitness
    • Health
    • Investment
    • Lifestyle
    • Marketing
    • Politics
    • Small Business
    • Technology
    • Top Stories
    • Travel
    About Us

    Small Business Minder brings together business and related news from around the world in one place. Follow us for all the business news you'll need.

    Facebook X (Twitter)
    Our Picks

    The Garmin Cirqa Finally Got a Much-Needed Feature

    October 26, 2026

    25 Simple Hacks That’ll Improve Your Quality Of Life

    October 26, 2026
    Most Popular

    Former FBI, CIA Head Has ‘Serious Concerns’ With Trump Cabinet Picks

    December 28, 2024435

    Emirates to operate next-gen A350 on the third daily service to Cape Town

    January 14, 2026256
    Categories
    © 2026 Small Business Minder
    • Home
    • Get In Touch

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. To get the most from our site, please disable your Ad Blocker.